College Admission

AI Is Changing College Admissions as Students and Universities Race to Stay Ahead

The traditional college application essay, once regarded as a personal window into a student’s character, creativity and ambitions, is facing an identity crisis as artificial intelligence increasingly becomes part of the admissions process.

Across the United States, high school students are turning to AI-powered tools to brainstorm ideas, refine personal statements, research universities and even generate application essays. At the same time, colleges are exploring similar technology to assess applications, creating a growing debate over fairness, authenticity and the future of university admissions.

With the January 1 deadline for the Common Application approaching, students are increasingly relying on platforms such as ChatGPT and Claude, sometimes in place of professional college advisers whose services can cost thousands of dollars.

However, the growing use of AI has left universities struggling to establish clear boundaries between acceptable assistance and academic dishonesty.

For some admissions officers, the challenge is not simply identifying AI-generated writing but determining whether an application genuinely reflects the person submitting it.

Kate Gilbertson, a 2025 graduate of the University of California, Berkeley, who now works full-time editing college applications, said she has noticed a growing number of essays that lack the imperfections typically associated with teenage writing.

She explained that small grammatical inconsistencies and unusual expressions often help establish whether a student’s writing retains an authentic personal voice.

Her observation reflects a wider concern among admissions professionals: as AI-generated content becomes increasingly sophisticated, distinguishing a student’s original work from machine-assisted writing is becoming more difficult.

Universities struggle to establish common AI rules

Although AI has become a regular feature of the application process, American universities have yet to agree on a uniform approach to its use.

Ashley Pallie, Dean of Undergraduate Admissions at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech), acknowledged that students are adapting to AI much faster than universities can develop policies to regulate it.

Caltech, which has a strong reputation for scientific research and technological innovation, has adopted a relatively flexible approach.

The institution considers using AI to generate ideas, develop questions and stimulate brainstorming acceptable. However, it discourages applicants from replacing their individual writing styles and personal voices with AI-generated material.

Pallie maintains that evaluating university applicants requires human judgement and cannot be reduced to an automated scoring system.

She argues that admissions decisions involve understanding individual experiences, motivations and potential, qualities that cannot easily be captured through a standardised formula.

Although Caltech uses AI in certain academic assessment activities, including reviewing students’ scientific research and generating questions for faculty members to examine, the institution does not consider the technology a substitute for human essay readers.

Other universities have introduced different restrictions. The University of Pennsylvania, for instance, has cautioned against using AI when preparing recommendation letters that are supposed to reflect the independent assessments of teachers and school counsellors.

Meanwhile, institutions dealing with enormous application volumes are exploring AI to improve efficiency.

Virginia Tech, which received a record 57,622 first-year applications for 2025, is among the universities experimenting with technology to manage the growing workload.

However, attempts to automate essay assessments have not always produced the desired results.

The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill reportedly abandoned plans to automatically score application essays based on writing quality after concerns emerged about the reliability of the process.

A university spokesperson attributed the problem partly to the widespread adoption of AI-assisted writing tools, which had reduced the usefulness of automated essay evaluations.

The situation highlights an emerging contradiction: universities are considering AI to manage applications while struggling to determine how much assistance students should be allowed to receive from the same technology.

Is artificial intelligence making the college essay obsolete?

The growing uncertainty surrounding AI has also prompted some universities to reconsider whether supplemental essays should remain a compulsory part of their admissions requirements.

Tulane University, for example, removed its traditional ‘Why Tulane?’ essay from its application requirements for the current cycle.

University spokesperson Michael Strecker confirmed that concerns about artificial intelligence influenced the decision, although he noted that the essay had not played a particularly significant role in admissions decisions in recent years.

For Sophie Sajnani, a 2025 college graduate who founded a specialised college consulting firm, the increasing use of AI does not necessarily mean students are losing their ability to express themselves.

Sajnani discourages applicants from depending on AI to generate their initial ideas but is more comfortable with its use in producing written drafts.

She explained that many young applicants are already familiar with AI technology and have trained their chatbots to reproduce their individual communication styles.

Her consulting firm has also recorded increased interest in its AI literacy programme, suggesting that students are becoming more interested in learning how to use the technology effectively.

According to Sajnani, the real purpose of an admissions essay is not necessarily to demonstrate exceptional writing skills but to reveal how an applicant has experienced personal growth.

She believes universities are more interested in understanding the circumstances students have faced and how those experiences have shaped their development.

Students themselves are also challenging the perception that using AI automatically amounts to cheating.

Anisah Ali, a high school junior in Washington, said she views the technology as a tool for exploring ideas and discovering possibilities rather than simply bypassing the application process.

For her, AI can help students consider perspectives and approaches they might not have arrived at independently.

Pallie, however, believes the traditional essay may eventually play a smaller role in university admissions.

She suggested that universities could increasingly rely on direct interactions with applicants, including personal interviews, to understand their character and motivations.

Importantly, she believes such interactions should remain human-led.

AI offers students access to affordable college guidance

Beyond essay writing, artificial intelligence is transforming how students identify suitable universities and navigate the complicated admissions process.

Traditionally, families with sufficient financial resources could hire private college consultants to research institutions, compare admission requirements, assess scholarship opportunities and guide students through applications.

However, these services are often beyond the reach of many households.

AI is beginning to bridge that gap by giving students access to personalised information and research assistance at little or no cost.

OpenAI recently introduced a college planning tool within ChatGPT, designed to help teenagers navigate the university application process.

Popular requests include generating questions to develop application ideas, reviewing essay drafts and checking the evidence used in written submissions.

Michael Koppenheffer, Chief Innovation Officer of Enrollment Solutions at EAB, an education technology and research organisation, described AI as an increasingly important alternative for students who cannot afford professional college counselling.

He noted that the technology enables applicants to access more detailed information and guidance than they might otherwise obtain.

Research conducted by EAB also suggests that AI is becoming a significant influence on students’ university choices.

Its findings indicate that 82 per cent of surveyed students who were asked about the AI tools they used during their college search identified ChatGPT.

Families are already using AI to make university decisions

The practical benefits of AI are becoming evident in how parents and students research potential universities.

Christine Wilson, who operates a marketing agency in Virginia and already incorporates AI into her business activities, initially engaged a college counsellor to help her son, Ronan, identify suitable universities.

However, the family eventually decided to use AI to reassess their options.

Wilson used Claude to develop a spreadsheet comparing the 22 universities her son applied to.

The tool analysed factors such as tuition costs, household income and potential financial aid, helping the family evaluate the financial implications of attending different institutions.

She said the process saved her many hours of research.

Wilson and her son also conducted a separate assessment of universities based on their availability of football programmes, Greek life and reputable business schools.

Ronan eventually chose the University of Florida.

Another parent, Bunmi Emenanjo, has also turned to AI while helping her 17-year-old daughter identify potential universities.

Her daughter has specific requirements for her future institution, including an urban location, merit-based financial assistance and a diverse student population.

Unlike the family’s experience with their older son, for whom they hired a professional college counsellor, they are relying primarily on Claude to research suitable institutions this time.

Emenanjo explained that using AI makes it easier to identify universities that meet the family’s requirements without having to visit individual university websites and manually gather the information.

However, she said her daughter would maintain a more traditional approach to the actual application, particularly when writing her personal essays.

The future of university admissions

The growing presence of artificial intelligence in college applications raises fundamental questions about what universities should be evaluating: a student’s writing ability, their capacity to use emerging technology or their individual experiences and potential.

For students, AI offers an opportunity to access guidance, research and writing assistance that was previously more readily available to families who could afford private consultants.

For universities, however, the technology presents a difficult balancing act between improving administrative efficiency and ensuring that admissions decisions remain fair and genuinely reflective of applicants.

As institutions experiment with automated assessments while introducing restrictions on AI-assisted applications, the traditional college essay may undergo significant changes.

The bigger challenge may no longer be determining whether students are using artificial intelligence, but establishing how they can use it responsibly without losing the personal experiences, independent thinking and individual voices that university applications are intended to reveal.

Oh hi there 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, every week.

We don’t spam!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *